a) Capability to provide infrastructure |
- 35 marks |
b) Capability to provide finance |
- 35 marks |
c) Educational qualifications |
- 15 marks |
d) Age |
- 4 marks |
e) Experience |
- 4 marks |
f) Business ability/acumen |
- 5 marks |
g) Personality |
- 2 marks |
Total |
100 marks |
" TO WHOMSOEVER IT MAY CONCERN
Stamp
Yours faithfully
sd/-
Manager"
12. The other certificate relied on by the Selection Committee is the Experience Certificate issued by Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company Limited which reads as under:" TO WHOMSOEVER IT MAY CONCERN
OFFICIAL SEAL
Sd/-
Senior Branch Manager
Bajaj Allianz
Up Hill, Malappuram"
13. The Degree Certificate issued by Cochin University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Technology dated 23.12.2008 shows that the appellant has been awarded the degree of Master of Technology in Software Engineering and the appellant qualified with First class distinction at the examination held in June, 2008. 14. The experience certificates issued by M/s Sree Agencies and M/s Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company Ltd. were evaluated by the Selection Committee. It has already been stated in the counter affidavit filed by the Corporation that the quality of experience will be judged on the basis of the response to the questions related to experience in direct sale, home delivered products, hospitality/service industry etc. by the candidates in the interview. It has also been informed to this Court that the appellant has been awarded 4 marks for experience by the Selection Committee consisting of 3 senior officials of the Company who are well qualified and experienced in assessing the required experience for LPG distributorship. It is further asserted that after the interview, field verification had been done by the Corporation to verify the genuineness and veracity of the documents submitted by the candidate as contemplated in clause 16 of the guidelines. It is further stated that the field verification had been conducted by a team comprising of 2 officers of the Corporation and that the team had met the Proprietor as well as Manager of M/s Sree Agencies, who confirmed that Mr. Sajeesh Babu K. (appellant herein) worked with them on a part-time basis. It is the stand of the Corporation that since the persons who have issued the experience certificate admitted its issuance, the Corporation treats the same as genuine. They also reiterated and verified that the certificates of experience have no relevance in granting marks under the parameter 'experience' as the same has been awarded on the basis of the response to the questions related to experience in the relevant field. The marks awarded by the Selection Committee are as follows:-
Name |
Edu. Quali. |
Age |
Experience |
Business ability |
Personality |
Total Marks |
Santhosh N.K. |
15 |
2 |
3 |
3.17 |
1.83 |
25 |
Sajeesh Babu K. |
15 |
2 |
4 |
3.83 |
2 |
26.83 |